5 Cheaper Alternatives to Xfinity with Fiber Internet

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Changing your Internet service provider can be very complicated. This can often mean trading one set of discounts and fees for another, then finding the best place to install your router. If you’re considering switching and using Comcast’s Xfinity, you don’t have to just accept what your ISP offers you. There are other options offering fiber optic internet at similar prices. The real trick is knowing which plans to compare yours to and what terms could actually save you money in the long run.

As of this writing, Xfinity is currently announcing three main pricing tiers for new subscribers. You can get 300 Mbps less for around $45 per month, or you can spend a little more for 500 Mbps less for $60 per month. If you need the faster speeds offered by Xfinity, like its 1GB service, you have to pay $70 per month. Each of these options also includes discounts for autopay and other such factors, which are something to be aware of when you start comparing plans from other providers.

The good news is that there are several providers offering plans at comparable prices. Whether or not these providers are available in your area is another question entirely, but it’s something you’ll have to check for yourself. We also recommend checking the total price of any plan after any type of introductory discount, because sometimes Internet service providers like Xfinity, AT&T, Verizon and others offer introductory prices that change after a few months or a year.

AT&T is easily one of the most recognizable companies you’ll see on this list. Although they’ve gained a reputation for jacking up prices in the past, AT&T’s fiber prices are actually relatively comparable to what Xfinity currently offers. Based on current deals, AT&T fiber starts at $35 per month for 300 Mbps less, with faster speeds such as 500 Mbps and 1 GB less available for $50 and $65. The good news is that you won’t need to add a phone plan to get these prices, although discounts may be available for bundling your services. Companies like AT&T tend to offer these types of discounts as an incentive for customers to keep their services under one roof.

There are some requirements you need to be aware of if you want to take advantage of these lower prices, which includes setting up automatic payment and paperless billing. These offers may also only be available to customers in certain markets. So you’ll need to see exactly what price range you’re looking for for your specific region.

The most important thing to look out for when going with AT&T fiber or another major ISP like it is to see exactly how long the discount you get for signing up will last. For example, Xfinity’s comparison price is guaranteed for five years; However, AT&T may not offer the same guaranteed price for as long, depending on where you live.

The next option on our list of Xfinity alternatives is Verizon Fios. Verizon’s fiber service is another solid way to get cheaper internet if you want to move away from Xfinity altogether.

Just like AT&T, Verizon offers an assortment of different plan options. You can get speeds of up to 300 Mbps starting at $40 per month, or the fast 500 Mbps plan for $75. If you want to enjoy 1GB or more services, then you will need to consider $90 or more.

Not all of the prices Verizon offers are cheaper than Xfinity, but you can at least get into a comparable range. If you’re unhappy with your Xfinity service, this might not be a bad option. As with any Internet service provider, it’s important to consider other fees you may face when creating an account. These may include a setup fee, which may be added to the initial bill or required before your service can be set up. Verizon also offers a three-year price guarantee on some plans and a five-year warranty on others. So, you’ll have at least that to look forward to if you decide to go with Fios.

Optimum is another solid option if you’re looking for cheap fiber internet access. Prices start at $30 per month for 300 Mbps less and go up to $40 per month for 500 Mbps less. Optimum also offers a 1GB service for just $50 per month, with a super-fast 2GB option for just $60. The lowest prices include a $10 discount for autopay and paperless billing, so if you don’t want to use those two features, you’ll have to pay a little more.

One thing that makes Optimum a particularly good option if it’s available in your area is the fact that each of these plans comes with a five-year price lock. This means that if you sign up and get 1GB for $50 per month, you’ll be locked into that price for the next 5 years.

You won’t have to worry about changing your Internet connection again or worry about the base price of your service randomly increasing. Fees and other charges can change or fluctuate, however, so that’s something to keep in mind.

Much like Optimum, Quantum Fiber is another solid provider for those who want cheaper Internet access without the worry of being tied to a larger ISP like Xfinity. Technically, Quantum is owned by AT&T, but the provider works separately and offers its own plan options, just as some smaller carriers, such as Metro by T-Mobile, work separately from the larger T-Mobile entity.

As for pricing, it really depends on what’s available in your area, but the company offers speeds ranging from 500 Mbps all the way up to 2 or even 8 Gbps, with its 1 Gig plan available for just $50 per month starting September 29, 2026. This price appears to require autopay and paperless billing to take full advantage of it. Quantum doesn’t require a contract to get its best price, but there’s no mention of price-lock guarantees, so the rate could be subject to change over time. Still, $50 a month for gig Internet service isn’t great, especially if you can cancel and switch to another ISP at any time.

Like other small ISPs, the biggest problem with Quantum is that it will all depend on whether or not it is available in your area. You can check availability on the Quantum website, and that will also give you a full breakdown of prices in your area.

If you’re looking for another cheap alternative to Xfinity’s 500 Mbps plan, Frontier is also a solid option. Frontier’s comparable Fiber 500 plan starts at $44.99 for new customers, although this requires both autopay and paperless billing to take full advantage. The company also offers other fiber Internet plans, like 1Gbps for $64.99 and up to 7GB service for $124.99 per month. The nice thing about Frontier’s offering is that the company advertises download speeds to match its plans, meaning you can expect to get both 500s up and down, which is ideal if you spend as much time sending files as receiving them.

Depending on the plan you choose, Frontier also advertises the use of eero Pro 7 routers as one of the benefits it offers. This is good because it ensures that you have a router that is designed to work with fiber optic internet. Some of the plans posted on Frontier’s website suggest the company could even offer free months for signing up.

The plans also come with a price lock guarantee, although the exact number appears to vary from four to five years depending on the option chosen. It’s worth noting that Frontier is owned by Verizon, but the company has different offerings than Verizon while also providing bundled opportunities for users of both.

When we sat down to put together a list of solid Xfinity alternatives, we knew we wanted to focus on two main things. First, the options had to offer similar speeds at cheaper (or at least comparable) prices. Second, we wanted to make sure to include names that are not only known but generally trusted by users. This meant that ISPs that were too specialized and super local weren’t going to succeed.

Unfortunately, there is no way to guarantee that an ISP will be available in your area. As such, you will need to check each provider specifically to see whether or not they offer service in your area. However, upgrading to fiber optic internet can have big benefits, so if you can get a good deal, it can definitely be worth it.